I really enjoyed Berghoff Root Beer nearly 3 years ago, so I had high hopes for their Black Cherry:
Brand: Berghoff Black Cherry Soda.
Origin: Chicago, IL.
Purchase Place: "Minnesota's Largest Candy Store," Jordan, MN.
Sweetener: Cane Sugar.
Review: From the first sip, I knew it was a unique black cherry soda. But I wasn't sure if I loved it right away. It was a little creamier than I would hope from a black cherry soda. It was definitely more like a "cream soda" than a "cola." In the end, I never fully got over the creaminess. It was OK, and you'd like it if you were in the mood for a cherry *cream* soda, but I'll give it just an average score.
Score: 5 out of 10.